Jen-Hsun Huang, president and chief executive officer of nVidia. Unfortunately, the Trustee misunderstands the relevant accounting concepts. Wagner’s valuation opinion is simply not persuasive. However, nVidia disputes that the hiring it did amounts to the acquisition of a workforce either as part of the Transaction or in connection with it and asserts that employees are not intangible assets. Peddie described the Gigapixel merger as a “desperate move” which was difficult to link with a rational business purpose.

Uploader: Marg
Date Added: 18 February 2004
File Size: 24.51 Mb
Operating Systems: Windows NT/2000/XP/2003/2003/7/8/10 MacOS 10/X
Downloads: 51414
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]

In response, he stated:. Bank of America Nat.

They began working at nVidia in early January In Atchison, as in this case, there was an asset interactivve, following which the selling company closed, and its terminated employees were hired by the purchaser. Wagner states that he adjusted these numbers to reflect the final terms of the Transaction. CourtListener is a project of Free Law Projecta federally-recognized c 3 non-profit.

Areas of Disagreement a.

It is 3dfd the engineers themselves. Grabowski concluded that the fair market value of the Trademarks was immaterial because no significant cash flows would be generated from their use.

On the other hand, if the terms are clear, the Court is to apply the meaning that would be ascribed by a reasonable third party.

The Summary Judgment Order does not establish the Trustee’s prima facie case, nor does it shift the burden of production or burden of proof to nVidia. The Transaction did not involve the transfer of a graphics business, business unit, engineers as peopleor a workforce.

In Re 3dfx Interactive, Inc., B.R. –

The Trustee also offered testimony by designated deposition excerpts for Paul Carmichael, Richard Heddelson, Steve Pettigrew as part of his case-in-chief. In both these cases, the courts refused to find the newly hired employees were intangible assets or embodied the goodwill of the former employer. On April 18, substantially all of 3Dfx’s assets were sold to Nvidia Sub. There was no evidence that 3dfx had any personnel to perform the critical specialized functions of a graphics business identified by Mr.


We rely on inreractive for our financial security. Wagner did not define 3dfz he meant by the term business in his Declaration or his Report.

Resolution of this issue requires a review of language in the APA, the opinions of the industry and valuation experts, the testimony of the witnesses actually involved in running 3dfx, and certain accounting definitions and rules.

After approximately 30 days, nVidia obtained regulatory approval of the Transaction. Wagner stated that using the price-per-engineer was a common valuation metric widely employed by a variety of reputable companies and investment banks during this time period.

However, nVidia disputes that the hiring it did amounts to the acquisition of a workforce either as part of the Transaction or in connection with it and asserts that employees are not intangible assets.

Archived from the original on Wagner testified that, in general, to constitute a business, an enterprise needs a product, sales, sales people, a marketing function, a human resources function, legal, accounting, and finance departments, managers for these various functions, a physical location, people to handle customer relationships and various distribution channels.

Pursuant to the Joint Statement and Pre-Trial Order, the issues, to be determined at this phase of the case are:. Just as GAAP rules regarding the book value of assets does sic not determine their fair market value, intefactive GAAP rules for treating debt as equity and vice versa are not relevant in determining whether they are truly debt or equity.


Wagner saying it 3dx so.

3dfx Interactive

Wagner’s approach to valuation required an ex ante point of view pursuant to which events occurring after the December 15, valuation date were to be used as a reasonableness check only. However, Napalm was delayed, and in the meantime Nvidia brought out their landmark GeForce chip, which shifted even more of the interqctive work from the CPU to the graphics chip.

CreditRiskMonitor is a financial risk analysis and news service for credit, supply chain and financial professionals. The Trustee argued that under “applicable accounting rules, if recorded goodwill is deemed to be interactkve i. Murphy, nVidia’s investment banking expert, testified that a business: What was important to nVidia in this transaction was not the value of the assets that we were buying, but the opportunity to be first in line to recruit the 3dfx design engineers.

Some of these engineers designed graphics chips and 3dfx incorporated those chips into intwractive own add-in boards. Did 3dfx Transfer a Graphics Business? Phil Carmack, senior vice president of the handheld GPU business unit of nVidia, former vice president of hardware engineering at 3dfx and former executive vice president of research and development unc 3dfx. Settlement of the Patent Litigation Mr.

Author: admin